I have the Puig tinted. I really haven’t used it much yet, but the few things I’ve noticed are it is better than the original, won’t get the tinted one again ( more difficult to see up close on dirt roads), still a lot of wind on shoulders @ highway speed, and windshield slant is adjustable. Couldn’t tell if Givi has slant adjustment or not. Haven’t played with the slant adjustment yet, but hope to have highway & off-road settings. I may be a little spoiled on the wind I expected, because I also have Triumph Trophy, the wind on the two is like night & day.